Thanks to PYP member Wanitaof3 for finding this deal for us, and trying it out this morning! From the PYP forums:
Buy 4 Breyers ice cream 16 oz. pints for $4 (available in chocolate and vanilla)
Use 2 $1/2 coupons HERE and HERE.
Use 2 Albertson’s doublers
Final price: FREE
Then, you’ll get a $4/5 Catalina coupon at checkout.
Use that to buy 5 more, and you’ll pay just $1 total for the next 5!
Another $4/5 Catalina will print, so wash, rinse, and repeat!